Ingredients
(Serves 8–10 generously)
The Base:
• 2½ cups (8 oz / 225g) uncooked elbow macaroni (or cavatappi for extra sauce-holding power)
The Signature Dressing:
• 2 cups Miracle Whip (full-fat—this is authentic; see FAQ for mayo notes)
• ⅓ cup granulated sugar (adjust to ¼ cup if you prefer less sweetness)
• 3 tbsp yellow mustard (not Dijon—classic American yellow for tang)
• 2 tbsp dill pickle relish (drained well—this adds subtle crunch + briny depth)
• 2 tsp white vinegar (brightens the richness)
• ¾ tsp celery seed (the soul of this salad—don't skip!)
• ¼ tsp fine sea salt
• ¼ tsp freshly cracked black pepper
The Crunch Ensemble:
• 3 hard-boiled eggs, finely chopped (cool completely before adding)
• ¼ cup sweet onion (Vidalia or Walla Walla), finely diced
• 3 celery stalks, diced small (about 1 cup)
• 1 large red bell pepper, seeds removed, finely diced (about 1 cup)
Instructions
1. Cook pasta with purpose
Bring a large pot of lightly salted water to a rolling boil. Add macaroni and cook 8–10 minutes until just tender (al dente). Critical step: Immediately drain and rinse under cold running water for 60 seconds—this halts cooking and prevents mushiness. Spread on a clean towel to air-dry 10 minutes (excess water = watery salad).
2. Build the dressing like a pro
In a medium bowl, whisk Miracle Whip until smooth. Add sugar, mustard, relish, vinegar, celery seed, salt, and pepper. Whisk vigorously until completely homogenous—no sugar granules, no streaks. Taste: It should be sweet-tangy with a distinct celery seed perfume. Adjust sugar/vinegar if needed.
3. Fold—don't stir
In an extra-large bowl, combine cooled pasta and dressing. Using a silicone spatula, gently fold until every noodle glistens—no aggressive mixing (you'll break the pasta). Fold in eggs, onion, celery, and bell pepper just until distributed. Do not overmix—you want visible veggie pops.
4. The patience payoff
Cover surface directly with plastic wrap (prevents skin formation). Refrigerate at least 3 hours—ideally 6–8. This isn't optional: the pasta absorbs dressing, flavors meld, and celery seed infuses its magic. Stir gently once after 1 hour to redistribute dressing.
5. Serve with soul
Give one final gentle fold. Transfer to a chilled serving bowl. For authenticity: garnish with a single celery leaf and extra celery seed sprinkle. Serve cold—never room temperature.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I use mayonnaise instead of Miracle Whip?
A: You can—but it won't taste like authentic Amish macaroni salad. Miracle Whip's vinegar-sugar balance creates the signature sweet-tangy profile. For closest results: mix 1¾ cups mayo + ¼ cup sweet pickle relish + 1 tbsp sugar. But purists know—the real deal uses Miracle Whip.
Q: My salad turned watery overnight! Why?
A: Three culprits: (1) Pasta not rinsed/cold before dressing, (2) Veggies not patted dry (especially bell pepper), (3) Relish not drained well. Next time: dry everything thoroughly—and fold in veggies just before serving if making >24 hours ahead.
Q: Can I make this dairy-free?
A: Miracle Whip is already dairy-free (contains no milk products)—but check your brand's label. For vegan: use vegan Miracle Whip-style spread + ensure sugar is vegan (some refined sugars use bone char).
Q: How long does it keep?
A: 4 days max in airtight container. After day 3, veggies soften and pasta absorbs excess moisture—still safe, but texture suffers. Never freeze—dressing separates irreversibly.
Allergy Information
• Contains: Eggs, Soy (in Miracle Whip), Wheat (pasta)
• Dairy-free (Miracle Whip contains no dairy—verify brand)
• Nut-free | Fish-free
• Gluten-free option: Use GF pasta (corn/rice blend)—note texture will differ
Always check Miracle Whip label for facility cross-contamination warnings.
Nutrition Facts (per ¾-cup serving)
Calories: 290 • Protein: 6g • Fat: 14g (Sat: 2.5g) • Carbs: 36g • Fiber: 2g • Sugar: 12g • Sodium: 480mg
Rich in Selenium, Folate, and Vitamin C
This salad carries stories in its curves—the church basement where it fed 200 after a funeral, the tailgate where it cooled sunburned shoulders, the reunion table where cousins fought over the last spoonful. It asks for nothing fancy. Just attention to detail: rinse the pasta, drain the relish, wait the three hours.
And that celery seed? It's more than spice. It's the fingerprint of a tradition that values community over complexity, generosity over glamour. One bite, and you understand: this isn't just a side dish. It's an invitation to sit awhile. To pass the bowl. To belong.
One last truth: The best Amish macaroni salad is always made by someone else's grandmother. But yours? It'll be the one people ask for the recipe—and quietly hope you bring again next year
.png)
.png)
